Why Price-Matching Advertising Is A Slippery Slope Down The Drain

You’ve seen the headlines. Maybe it’s even plastered all over your local CO-OP. “We’re price-matching Aldi!” they shout, standing tall like they’ve just reinvented the retail game.

But here’s the brutal truth they don’t want to hear (and neither do you, if you’re making the same mistake): price-matching isn’t strategy.

It’s desperation wearing a fancy sandwich board.

CO-OP vs. Aldi: The Free PR Gift Aldi Never Asked ForLook, CO-OP, I get it.

Aldi looms large with their no-frills aisles, wallet-friendly prices, and reputation as budget champions.

You're scrambling to grab a piece of that action.

But ask yourself this, and answer honestly – does shouting “We’re as cheap as Aldi!” make anyone reach for their car keys and think, “Brilliant, I’ll go to the CO-OP instead”?

The short answer? No. The long answer? Hell no.

Here’s what customers actually hear when you play the price-match game:

• If Aldi’s the benchmark, why not just go to Aldi? (They’ve got the vibe, the credibility, and the memes.)

• The CO-OP doesn’t stand for anything anymore. They’ve hitched their wagon to the competition instead of charting their own course.

  
  

And while you yell, “We’re as cheap as you!” from the top of your lungs, Aldi sits back, smirks, and basks in the free advertising you’ve just handed them. Job done.

They win the psychological war without lifting a finger.

This isn’t CO-OP’s first PR kerfuffle, and it won’t be the last if they keep waging war on territory they have no business fighting for. Because when you compete on price, you’re not fighting with your competition. You’re fighting for them.

The Race To The Bottom

Price wars have destroyed more businesses than bad logos and bored accountants combined. And here’s why.

When you make price your ace card, you’re saying, “We have nothing else to offer that’s worth paying more for.” Even worse, you’re teaching your customers to always hunt for the lowest price, which is a never-ending hamster wheel of shrinking margins and stressed-out balance sheets.

Think of Woolworths. A brand loved by generations but crippled by its pursuit of cheapness.

Instead of leaning into the nostalgia and uniqueness customers loved, they became a shadow of themselves, trying to out-budget Tesco and Sainsbury’s at the expense of their soul. Spoiler alert? They didn’t win.

Want more? How about BHS? They played the cheap game and got buried by it. The collapse wasn’t just an economic failure; it was proof that price-driven businesses often lose when competitors bring sharper operational efficiency or better branding firepower.

Price slashing does one thing really well:It makes your competition stronger, your brand weaker, and your customers more loyal to their wallets than to you.

Why Differentiation Matters More Than Ever

You can’t out-Aldi Aldi. You can’t out-Primark Primark. And you definitely can’t out-Amazon Amazon. But here’s the kicker – you don’t have to.

What businesses need is D-I-F-F-E-R-E-N-T-I-A-T-I-O-N. Something that makes people stand up and say, “I need to experience that.” Something Aldi can’t emulate, no matter how big their middle aisle grows.

Here’s the thing no one wants to admit. Competing on price is a lazy cop-out when you’re too scared (or uninspired) to stand out.

Real players in the game create offers Aldi could never touch with a bargain sticker. They win not by matching prices but by owning VALUE.

Think about Apple.They thrive on premium pricing. Why? Because their customers buy into the lifestyle, not the specs. They queue through the night for new launches, not because Apple products are cheap but because they feel significant.

Or take Patagonia.Their gear isn’t cheap, yet loyalists shell out for it because the brand resonates deeply on values like sustainability and activism that competitors can’t replicate with a 20% discount.

Actionable Advice For Businesses Who Want To Win

If you’re going to take on the big dogs, stop measuring yourself against them. Focus on creating distinction instead of falling into the cheap-and-cheerless pit of price wars. Here’s how:

1. Lead with Purpose, Not Price.

What do you stand for? If your answer is “low prices,” you’ve already lost. Customers will forget what you charge, but never how you made them feel. Take a stance. Shout it loud. Own it.

2. Find Your Edge. No, Really.

What makes you tick? What do you offer that’s distinctly YOU? Whether it’s premium quality, killer customer service, or standing up for something bigger than the bottom line, double down on your difference.

3. Tell A Story No One Else Can.

Humans don’t fall in love with spreadsheets. They fall in love with stories. Build a narrative around your brand that Aldi (or any competitor) wouldn’t dream of claiming. Bring your audience into the heart of it and make them part of something meaningful.

4. Educate, Don’t Beg.

Teach your customers to value quality, experience, and innovation. Show them why you charge what you do. Make your prices not just acceptable but justifiable. Selling at a race-to-the-bottom rate screams fear. Selling proudly screams confidence.

5. Stop Competing, Start Creating.

Think back to the giants mentioned earlier. Patagonia doesn’t apologize for its price tag. Apple laughs all the way to the bank. Why? Because they’ve created something that feels exclusive, aspirational, and purpose-driven. Create a movement, not just a product.

Final Word

The CO-OP’s price-matching campaign against Aldi? It’s like bringing a dull butter knife to a gunfight. And worse, aiming it at themselves. The only winners are Aldi and the customers who never planned to pay a penny more than necessary anyway.

Price matching isn’t savvy. It’s suicide by irrelevance.

Here’s the truth everyone needs to hear, but few accept: the fight isn’t about being cheaper. It’s about being different.

It’s about driving your audience to choose you because they value what only you can bring to their lives. Cheap is easy. Meaningful? That’s where the hard, rewarding work lives.

Because at the end of the day, no one remembers the cheapest. They remember the boldest.

Brands, businesses, future leaders: Stop slashing. Start standing. Innovate, inspire, and differentiate. Or keep digging the grave for your own mediocrity. Your move.

John (Nick) Atkinson, The CreActivist Marketer who is Doing it Differently!

"Price wars cut too deep,

Voices lost in the cheap noise.

Stand out. Be yourself."

Hey, want to keep in touch with Missives and so much more? Sign up here for

free golden nuggets into your inbox!